TiVo vs. Windows Media Center
My sister and her husband gave me a very nice Christmas present this year - their spare TiVo plus an annual subscription. They say if I like they can just renew it each year for me rather than buying a present. Not a bad deal, but I told them I will think on it.
You see, I already have Media Center on my computer. But TiVo was the version I first tried out, back when it first came out and one of my other sisters had it. And I’ve long thought that I like it best.
Don’t get me wrong. Media Center is nice. It came with my computer that I was buying anyhow, and all I had to do was get the tuner card so that it could receive cable channels. No subscription fees.
Each one has some advantages and disadvantages.
TiVo Advantages:
- Designed just for the television.
- Great operating system. Easier to interact with in many ways.
- I like watching my shows on the television.
- Makes suggestions of shows you might like to watch, and records them. This can be turned off if/when it drives you nuts.
- I think the picture quality is better in my experience.
TiVo Disadvantages:
- Subscription fees.
- Watching a lot of television on the television means I work less.
- If you just want to record, for example, the 9:00 showing of a show every week, you can’t just type in the name and tell it to do it. You have to go by time and channel for this. Otherwise the subscription will go for all showings. This is a pain if it’s on a channel that does a lot of reruns, such as the Discovery Channel.
- My own problem - living room is really not set up for an internet connection or telephone connection, so we have a cord running through the house to the nearest phone outlet. We hope to eventually do wireless internet, but it’s not in the budget now.
Media Center Advantages:
- No subscription fees.
- Sometimes it’s nice to watch television on my computer monitor.
- Add on for the computer. Designed to deal with much more than just recording and watching television.
- Could be set up to work with the television if I cared to do it. They’re in separate rooms, so it’s not happening for me.
- When you decide you need to program in a show you’d like to record, what you are currently watching appears in a small screen near the bottom, so you don’t stop watching completely.
- You can choose the airtime of shows you want to record, so episodes run at other times do not record.
Media Center Disadvantages:
- Add on for the computer. Designed to deal with much more than just recording and watching television. Yes, good and bad.
- Watching a lot of television on the computer means I work less.
- I’ve always felt the picture quality was poorer.
- Took a very long time to figure out how to change show priorities. You have to go to the Scheduled recording section, then switch to series before you can mess around with recording priority on anything other than a case by case basis.
All in all, it’s interesting having both. I don’t know if my preferences will change or not over time. One plus to having both that I’ve already noticed is that my husband and I can more easily enjoy our preferred shows separately and together. With Media Center on my computer, not his, he hasn’t always been able to watch his shows as easily as I could watch mine.
Technorati Tags: tivo, media center, television, dvr





